The Radicalization of the Extreme Right
The Rallies in Charlottesville in August 2017 and Chemnitz in August 2018
In August 2017, members of multiple far-right movements rallied in Charlottesville, Virginia, with the goals of uniting the American white nationalist movement and opposing the removal of a statue of Robert E. Lee. The rally turned violent, ending with dozens of injuries and the murder of counter-protestor Heather Heyer. A year later, members of the far right movement rioted in Chemnitz, Germany, against immigrants and refugees. On November 27, 2018, DAAD/AICGS Research Fellow Prof. Dr. Hajo Funke gave a seminar on the developments in both cases, especially on the conditions of radicalization by certain organizing groups and their specific, often violent and dangerous parts, particularly their neo-Nazi orientation. The seminar examined the similarities and differences of neo-Nazi ideologies and grouping; the reaction of security institutions, especially the police, during the two events; and the public and political reactions.
- Right wing populism and radicalism is on the upswing worldwide.
- For many, it offers “solutions” in scapegoats and provides an outlet for rage.
The Case of Chemnitz
- The spark for the August 2018 riots was the killing of a Cuban German by refugees.
- Organization: a neo-Nazi football supporters club organized on social media and marched, threatening violence toward refugees and destroying “stumbling stones,” plaques remembering Holocaust victims. The gathering was a spontaneous reaction to a current event.
- Setting: Eastern Germany is known for having multiple hotspots of right wing nationalism; Chemnitz was considered a safe city for right wing nationalists.
- Reaction of security services: Police were unable to stop the marches or the violence. Efforts are being made to remedy the weak security response. Security forces are still struggling to find ways to deal with misinformation and right-wing organization spread through social media.
- Political reaction: The right wing Alternative for Germany stood with PEGIDA and the neo-Nazi demonstrators in Chemnitz on September 1. It was shocking to many Germans that a party sitting in Parliament would send representatives to publicly support violent, racist, and xenophobic views. Chancellor Merkel condemned the violence without reservation, as did Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer.
- Public reaction: On October 13, 2018, approximately 250,000 demonstrators gathered in Berlin under the slogan “unteilbar” (indivisible) to protest the far right and support marginalized groups in Germany.
The Case of Charlottesville
- The spark for the August 2017 demonstrations was the removal of a statue of Robert E. Lee.
- Organization: Jason Kessler and Richard Spencer, both white supremacists, planned a rally to bring together the various alt-right, alt-light, and confederate supporter organizations in the United States. This was planned far in advance of the removal of the statue.
- Setting: Charlottesville is a small, liberal-leaning college town; very different from Chemnitz where there was already an extremist presence.
- Reaction of security services: Police units were in chaos, without communication, and at one point pushed demonstrators into each other. A state of emergency was declared in Virginia, but it came too late for successful backup. Institutions are conducting legal proceedings against the murderer of Heather Heyer. Security forces are still struggling to find ways to deal with misinformation and right-wing organization spread through social media.
- Political reaction: President Donald Trump said there was blame “on both sides” when asked about the violence in Charlottesville. Attorney General Jeff Sessions described the car attack as domestic terrorism. Multiple senators, both republican and democrat, condemned the rally.
What is the political will of German and American institutions to deal with right wing extremism?
- In Germany, public struggle for a greater recognition of the rights of minorities depends on intensified civic engagement and defense of the Constitution against right-wing radical parties.
- The United States must face its historical legacy of slavery, racism, and segregation.
- Is the solution better security coordination? Both Germany and the United States must ensure that strengthened security services do not hurt the minority groups they are meant to protect.